top of page
Writer's pictureGlobal Stone of NY

The 8 Most Common Mistakes Homeowners Make When Renovating with Stone Tile (And How to Avoid Them)

Renovating your home with tile can instantly elevate the look and feel of your space, whether you choose stone tile, porcelain tile, mosaic tile, cement tile, or wood-look tile. However, while tile offers durability and aesthetic appeal, many homeowners make mistakes that can lead to costly repairs or disappointing results. In this article, we’ll explore the most common pitfalls people face when working with these tile materials, and provide tips on how to avoid them.


A proper stone tile installation can add equity to your home.


1. Choosing the Wrong Tile Material for Your Space

Each type of tile has its own set of benefits and drawbacks, which should be considered based on the room and its specific needs. For instance, while stone tile offers a timeless, natural look, it may require more maintenance due to its porous nature. On the other hand, porcelain tile is more durable and water-resistant, making it a great choice for bathrooms or kitchens.

Common Mistake: Many homeowners make the mistake of choosing a tile based solely on aesthetics, without considering its suitability for the room's function.

How to Avoid It: Before making a selection, research the different types of tiles. If you're looking for a rustic or luxurious look, stone tile is a great option for living areas and entryways. However, for wet areas like bathrooms or kitchens, porcelain tile or cement tile may be more practical. Also, consider the durability of mosaic tiles for smaller spaces or accents, and wood-look tiles for the appearance of wood without the maintenance.


2. Ignoring Stone Tile Subfloor Preparation

Tile is a heavy material, and for it to stay secure, your subfloor must be solid and level. Many homeowners overlook the importance of preparing the subfloor properly before laying the tile, which can lead to cracked tiles or uneven surfaces later on.

Common Mistake: Installing tile on an uneven or poorly prepared subfloor.

How to Avoid It :Ensure that your subfloor is stable, level, and dry. If you're working with existing flooring, such as old tile or hardwood, make sure to remove it and assess the condition of the subfloor underneath. For areas with moisture issues (like basements), use a waterproofing membrane or a cement board underlayment before installing tiles.


3. Failing to Account for Tile Grout Maintenance

Grout is essential for keeping tiles in place, but it can also be a maintenance headache. Mosaic tile, cement tile, and even stone tile often require specialized grout types to match the material and prevent staining or cracking.

Common Mistake: Choosing the wrong grout type or failing to seal grout lines, especially with stone tiles and cement tiles, which are more porous and susceptible to stains.

How to Avoid It: When selecting grout, consider its composition—sanded grout is typically best for larger joints, while unsanded grout works for smaller joints. Always apply a sealer to grout lines, especially in high-moisture areas. Regularly clean grout lines to prevent buildup, particularly with mosaic tile installations, which often have more grout lines.


4. Skipping Professional Installation

While DIY renovation projects can be fun, when it comes to installing stone tiles or cement tiles, precision is key. Many homeowners underestimate the complexity of laying tile correctly, leading to uneven or poorly aligned installations.


Common Mistake: Trying to install tile without professional help or the right tools.


How to Avoid It: If you’re not experienced with tile installation, hire a professional. This is especially important when working with large format tiles like porcelain tile or heavy stone tiles, which require specific tools, such as a wet saw, to ensure clean cuts and proper placement. Proper installation also ensures long-term durability and prevents costly mistakes.


5. Overlooking the Importance of Tile Layout


A poorly planned tile layout can make a space look disjointed or unbalanced. Whether you're using wood-look tile to mimic the appearance of hardwood or installing intricate mosaic tile designs, layout plays a critical role in achieving a cohesive and aesthetically pleasing result.


Common Mistake: Installing tiles haphazardly without planning the layout first.


How to Avoid It: Before starting, dry-lay the tiles in the space to determine the best arrangement. Consider the tile size and how it will flow with the dimensions of the room. For wood-look tile, ensure that the tiles are staggered to mimic natural wood planks. For mosaic tile, take your time to align the patterns, and consider creating focal points or borders that tie the room together.


6. Not Buying Enough Tile

Many homeowners fail to account for waste and mistakes during the installation process. Whether you’re using stone tile, cement tile, or mosaic tile, it’s important to purchase extra tiles to cover any breaks or cuts needed during the installation process.

Common Mistake: Underestimating how much tile is needed, leading to delays or mismatched tile designs if the original batch is no longer available.

How to Avoid It: It’s recommended to purchase at least 10-15% more tile than the area requires. This ensures you’ll have enough in case of mistakes, damaged tiles, or future repairs. If you're searching for tile stores near me, be sure to inquire if they carry extra stock or offer to order more tiles for you.


7. Not Considering Tile Maintenance Requirements


While tiles like stone tile and cement tile offer stunning aesthetics, they may require more maintenance than other materials. Stone tiles, for example, may need periodic sealing to prevent staining, while mosaic tile may require frequent grout cleaning.


Common Mistake: Underestimating the long-term care and maintenance of the tile material.


How to Avoid It: Make sure you’re prepared for the maintenance needs of your chosen tile. If you’re opting for stone tile, invest in a good-quality sealer and commit to reapplying it every 1-2 years. For cement tile, ensure that you use a suitable cleaner and avoid acidic substances that could damage the surface. For wood-look tiles, use appropriate cleaners to avoid dulling the finish.


8. Not Considering Long-Term Durability

Tile is a long-term investment, and while certain materials may be more stylish at the moment, it’s crucial to think about the durability and maintenance in the long run. For example, while wood-look tile offers the appearance of wood, it’s generally more durable and easier to maintain than natural wood flooring.

Common Mistake: Choosing a tile based solely on trend without considering long-term durability.

How to Avoid It: Choose tiles that balance style with practicality. Porcelain tile, for example, is durable, water-resistant, and relatively low-maintenance, making it a great option for both kitchens and bathrooms. For a more rustic or organic look, consider stone tile, but be aware of its maintenance needs over time.


Renovating with stone tile, porcelain tile, mosaic tile, cement tile, or wood-look tile can transform your home into a beautiful, functional space. By avoiding these common mistakes—such as choosing the wrong material, skipping professional installation, and neglecting maintenance—you can ensure that your renovation project runs smoothly and that your tiles remain beautiful and durable for years to come.


If you're ready to start your renovation journey, visit local tile stores near me to explore your options and get expert advice on choosing the best tile for your home.

bottom of page